Yankees have several high ceiling prospects returning from injuries with video
by Greg Corcoran
In the 2023 offseason one thing is for sure. The Yankees have already lost a ton of pitching depth and some high-end talent. They are, however, in a great position to replace that talent as early as next season. Between the draft, international prospects coming stateside, and players returning from injury, the Yankees have the goods on the farm to rapidly replenish the upper levels of the system with pitching. They also have a catcher returning from injury who could make a huge splash next year once he’s healthy. Starting with Engelth Urena, the lone positional prospect on this list, the names below could help mitigate the sting of the recent losses the farm system has suffered.
1. Engelth Urena – C, 5-foot-11, 196-pounds, right-handed, 19-years-old – Urena was expected to make his stateside debut in 2023, but injuries had their way with him, and he missed the entire season. Yankees insiders were expecting him to have a breakout season before he went down. By all accounts, Urena can do it all. He has a plus glove, framework, and arm defensively. Offensively, he has big power and makes frequent hard contact without striking out much. Missing almost two full seasons with injury will hurt his development, and that’s the biggest question going forward. There’s potential here for a big splash in 2024, so keep an eye on this name.
2. Angel Benitez – SP, 6-foot-7, 204-pounds, RHP, 20-years-old – Benitez missed all of 2023 after getting Tommy John Surgery following the 2022 season. In 2022, he threw 17 innings and had 24 K : 7 BB and a 1.06 ERA. Before the injury, Benitez sat in the mid-90’s and topped out at 97 mph with a fastball that has cutting action and ride. He also possesses a plus changeup and a sweeper that is already above average. He has a low arm slot with good extension. Many are excited about Carlos Lagrange and Henry Lalane, but what most don’t realize is that Angel Benitez might be the best of the bunch. Benitez will make the journey to the United States next season but mark my words, he will not do it quietly. He should be one of the most talked about players in the FCL next season if he can remain healthy.
3. Eric Reyzelman – – 6-foot-2, 188-pounds, SP, RHP, 22-years-old – The Yankees drafted Reyzelman in the 5th round in 2022 and he already had an upper 90’s fastball at that time. In college, he mainly threw the fastball, but he needs to develop his slider and changeup more to take his game to the next level. The Yankees bought on the upside and they’re hoping it pays off. It will if the development team can keep him healthy and get those secondary pitches going. This year he only threw 7.2 innings due to various nagging injuries. The biggest thing for Reyzelman will be to get innings under his belt next season. If he’s able to stay healthy, he could begin to make a name for himself in 2024. At the least, he has late inning relief pitcher written all over him.
4. Cam Schlittler – SP, 6-foot-6, 210-pounds, RHP, 22-years-old – Schlittler missed time due to various injuries in 2023, but he did manage to get 46 innings in. With the exception of the GCL, he struggled to keep his ERA down. Overall he had 50 K : 21 BB and a 4.11 ERA in 46 innings over three levels. Schlittler’s velocity dropped due to the injuries in 2023, sitting at around 90 mph and topping out at 93. He gets good vertical break on the four-seam fastball, but not much side-to-side movement. The slider, curveball, and changeup have good movement profiles though he often struggles with location. If he can improve his fastball velocity and movement while also increasing command, Schlittler could break out. He certainly has the size to do just that. Before he was drafted, he was hitting 95 mph so it’s probably in there somewhere.
5. Luis Gil – SP, 6-foot-2, 185-pounds, RHP, 23-years-old – Having thrown just eight innings in the past two seasons, Luis Gil had become a bit of a forgotten man. He returned late in the 2023 season and was flashing the same upper 90’s velocity as before with a knockout slider and improved changeup. Gil could return to form in 2024 and make a splash in the major league rotation or bullpen. First order of business will be to prove he can cut down on the walks. His first major league experience in 2021 was tantalizing, with a 3.07 ERA and 38 K : 19 BB in 29.1 innings. That performance would be a welcome addition to the Yankees in 2024. Still just 23, Gil has plenty of time to grow and carve out a nice career.
6. Brendan Beck – SP, 6-foot-2, 205-pounds, RHP, 25-years-old – Beck came back late in 2023 and had an eye-opening performance in 10 starts, mostly with the High-A Renegades. He ended up with a 1.59 ERA and 40 K : 7 BB in 34 innings. Beck has a low-90’s fastball that has reached the upper-90’s in the past. He pairs the fastball with a curveball, slider, and changeup. He has excellent command of all of these pitches and 2024 may be his coming out party. With the restrictions removed, Beck could have a similar breakout to what we saw from Drew Thorpe in 2023. It wouldn’t surprise me to see Beck among the top 10 prospects by this time next year.
7. Will Brian – SP, 5-foot-11, 220-pounds, LHP, 24-years-old – The Yankees originally drafted Will Brian with the expectation that he would be a reliever at the next level. They soon came to realize that he had four pitches with nasty movement which placed him in the conversation for the starting rotation. As such he began the 2023 season in that role, though he ended up injuring his UCL after just 6.1 innings. He should make it back at the tail end of 2024. With his recent velocity increase to the low-90’s topping out at 94.2 and filthy secondary pitches, Brian could begin to make his move through the organization shortly after his return.
8. Trystan Vrieling – SP, 6-foot-4, 200-pounds, RHP, 23-years-old – Vrieling didn’t debut until the Arizona Fall League in 2023. The performance was encouraging, especially considering the time he missed due to injury. Vrieling’s current go-to pitches are his high spin curveball and slider. He mixes the breaking balls with a fastball that sits 90-93 and tops out at 96. It was encouraging to see him strike out 15 in just 10.2 innings in the AFL, though his walk rate and ERA (5.06) could use some improvement. With a full, healthy offseason I’d expect both to improve and Vrieling could be in for a big 2024.
9. Luis Serna – SP, 5-foot-11, 162-pounds, RHP, 19-years-old – Serna made some noise when he debuted in the FCL as a 17-year-old and had a 1.96 ERA with 56 K : 17 BB in 41.1 innings. Unfortunately, he missed a lot of time due to nagging injuries in 2023 and managed just 19.1 innings. Serna has a four-pitch mix, all of which have good movement. He commands his arsenal as well as any 19-year-old around. His fastball sits at 92 mph and tops out at 94. He has a slider, curveball, and a changeup that might be the best in the system now that Drew Thorpe is gone. Serna has the polish to move quickly and could reach High-A by the end of 2024.
10. Omar Gonzalez – SP, 6-foot-4, 175-pounds, RHP, 18-years-old – Gonzalez had a fantastic debut season in 2022, with a 0.44 ERA and 36 K : 9 BB in 20.1 innings in the DSL. Unfortunately, he succumbed to Tommy John Surgery shortly after the start of the 2023 DSL season. Gonzalez is a strikeout machine and has a low-90’s fastball that has touched 93 with high spin rates and movement. He also throws a slider and a changeup which could both be above average. The early news in camp in 2023 was that his stuff had improved across the board, including velocity. Now we will have to wait until he comes back from injury to see if he can sustain those improvements. When he comes back, he should be in the United States, but that may not happen until 2025.